Sunday, July 21, 2019
Judicial Review problem question essay
Judicial Review problem question essay Judicial Review problem question (3000 words) Part 1 The first significant area for consideration in this scenario is whether Jack will be granted permission to proceed with his application for judicial review. He is seeking review of a decision by an internal disciplinary tribunal that he be dismissed for unprofessional conduct. The tribunal found unanimously in favour of dismissing Jack. In order to assess whether Jack will be permitted to pursue his claim for review, the nature of jusidical review must briefly be considered. Following the Bowman Report of 2000, in the light of Lord Woolfeââ¬â¢s recommendations for law reform, the regime of judicial review has been altered in certain ways. The 1977 reforms of the procedure did not state expressly that judicial review was an exclusive procedure.[1] It was in the case of Oââ¬â¢reilly v Mackman (1983) that the court considered the issue of exclusivity. In this case, the House of Lords held that it would be contrary to public policy to allow an applicant to seek to enforce public l aw rights by way of ordinary action rather than by way of judicial review. In the present instance, then, it must be considered whether the decision of the tribunal is a public or a private law matter. The ruling of the House of Lords in this case means that procedural exclusivity exists in cases of public law. In order to assess whether Jackââ¬â¢s case is one of public law, the common law must be considered in this area. In Cocks v Thanet District Council (1983), the House of Lords held that under the relevant Act in the case, the Housing (Homeless Persons) Act 1977, the housing authoritiesââ¬â¢ functions were essentially public law functions. These functions included deciding whether they had a duty to house the applicant under the 1977 Act. It was only after this decision had been made, and if it was considered that such a duty did exist, that private rights and obligations would arise. In Roy v Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Family Practitioner Committee (1992), the House of Lords held that an issue was concerned exclusively with a public right should be determined in judicial review proceedings. This strict application of the exclusivity principle, however, has been superceded by the more liberal approach characterised in the decision of Clark v University of Lincolnshire and Humberside (2000). In his judgement, Lord Woolfe explained the effects of the new Civil Procedure Rules on the rule in Oââ¬â¢reilly v Mackman. ââ¬Å"The intention of the CPR is to harmonise procedures as far as possible and to avoid barren procedural disputes which generate satellite litigation.â⬠[2] The important question has become whether failure to follow the correct procedure amounts to abuse of process of court. In the present case, then, the question of whether this matter is properly described as public law or private law is of the utmost significance. As long as Jack can satisfy the court that the functions of the tribunal are public law ones, he will most likely be granted permission to proceed with his claim. This, however, may be difficult. In R v Legal Aid Board, ex p Donn Co (1996), Ognall J stated that ââ¬Ëthere can be no universal testââ¬â¢ for deciding whether a matter is properly described as public law. If the tribunal is a public body, it will have derived its authority from statute or delegated legislation (as opposed to deriving powers from the agreement of those who are subject to the body). Some guidance as to what would constitute a public body was offered by the Court of Appeal in R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club, ex p Aga Khan (1993). Here it was held that although the Jockey Club regulated a significant national activity, it did not properly constitu te a public body, as it was not mentioned in statute, and its powers were simply over those who agreed to be bound by it. In Jackââ¬â¢s case, however, the tribunal does indeed derive its powers from statute. Furthermore, following R v Panel on Take-overs and Mergers, ex p Datafin plc (1987), the court should look to the nature of the functions the body performs, as well as its origins. The functions of the tribunal will be considered to be public law functions, and so in the light of the doctrine of exclusivity, Jack will be granted permission to proceed with his claim for judicial review. Part 2 There are various grounds that may arise for Jack to pursue his claim for judicial review in the scenario. Firstly, Jack is told by the tribunal that he may not have legal representation present. Furthermore, although he is entitled to have a friend or relative present at the proceedings, this person must not be legally qualified. Is this a breach of protocol? In other words, does Jack have a right to be represented at the Tribunal? It is established at common law that no such right exists. In the case of R v Board of Visitors of HM Prison, the Maze, ex p Hone, the appellants claimed that the Boardââ¬â¢s refusal to allow them to be legally represented at the disciplinary proceedings was counter to natural justice. Lord Goff, however, said ââ¬Å"it does not follow that simply because a charge before a disciplinary tribunal â⬠¦ relates to facts which in law constitute a crime, the rules of natural justice require the tribunal to grant legal representation.ââ¬â¢ According to this analysis, then, Jack does not necessarily have a right to legal representation. Whether legal representation is granted is a matter, in this instance, for the tribunal to decide. In doing so, it must take into account a number of factors. These include whether there are complex matters of law at issue (which it does not appear there are in this case); and whether Jack is incapable of presenting his own case. If fairness dictated that Jack should be allowed representation for either of these reasons, then of course he should be, but the tribunal appears to have acted within its rights to deny him this representation in the present instance. Lord Denning highlighted this principle in Pett v Greyhound Racing Association (1969): ââ¬ËIt is not every man who has the ability to defend himself on his own â⬠¦ He may be tongue-tied or nervous, confused or wanting in intelligence.â⬠Jackââ¬â¢s tribunal could make a case for denying Jack representation, and this is not there fore a suitable ground for his claim for judicial review. The second issue relates to the tribunalââ¬â¢s decision to limit Jackââ¬â¢s witnesses to five, as opposed to the ten he originally sought to act as character witnesses. There are two possible avenues which Jack could proceed down with this. The decision can be identified as falling within, perhaps, one of the original categories of grounds for judicial review as set out by Lord Diplock in Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service (1985). This ground was irrationality, which was likened in that case to the principle of unreasonableness identified in the other key case for judicial review, Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation (1948). This principle of irrationality applied, in Lord Diplockââ¬â¢s words, to ââ¬Ëa decision which I so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards that no sensible person who has applied his mind to the question to be decided would have arrived at it.ââ¬â¢[3] This was ada pted and mollified somewhat by Lord Cooke in R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Traderââ¬â¢s Ferry Ltd (1999), who asked ââ¬Ëwhether the decision in question was one which a reasonable authority would reach.ââ¬â¢ The problem of proceeding down this avenue, for Jack, is the high standard of proof which Jack must meet in order to be successful in his claim. He would need to show that the decision to limit his witnesses to five would not be reached by any reasonable person. Lord Ackner identified the reason for this high level of proof as being that judicial review is a supervisory process, not an appellate jurisdiction (R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Brind (1991)). It seems unlikely that Jack would succeed in establishing that this decision on the part of the tribunal was so irrational as to be worthy of judicial review. He would more likely be successful following the second potential avenue in relation to this decision of the tribunal; that of procedural impropriety, which was also one of the original grounds for judicial review identified in the GCHQ Case. This phrase encompasses both the breach of statutorily defined procedural rules, and also the breach of common law rules of natural justice. Jackââ¬â¢s claim in this area will depend in part on the procedural rules set out in the relevant statute governing employment tribunals. If the tribunal has not complied with statutory provisions by limiting Jackââ¬â¢s witnesses to five, it will be considered to have acted ultra vires. In this case, the tribunal has met with its statutory obligation under the Tribunals and Inquiries Act 1992, s10 to give reasons for its decision to limit the number of witnesses to five for each side (ââ¬Ëit would not be administratively expedient to allow the calling of such a large number of witnesses, particular ly as it is the view of the tribunal that many of the witnesses would not provide evidence which would have a material impact upon the outcome of the proceedingsââ¬â¢). It is a central principle of natural justice that Jack must be entitled to a fair hearing. It is in this area that Jack has the best chance of securing judicial review of the employment tribunalââ¬â¢s decision. Firstly, in relation to the composition of the panel, Jack has a valid complaint against the inclusion of a member of staff with whom he had a relationship that ended acrimoniously. This instantly raises the possibility of bias in the tribunal panel. English courts have developed two tests for bias, based on reasonable suspicion, and on real likelihood. In R v Gough (1993), however, it was held that the same test should be applicable in all cases of apparent bias. This test is whether there is a real danger of bias. Given the nature of the womanââ¬â¢s previous relationship to Jack, it is fair to suggest that there is a real danger of bias. This, then, according to the Gough test (despite subsequent challenges to that test in cases such as Porter v Magill (2002)), would g ive Jack a strong ground for seeking judicial review. Part 3 The grounds under which Jack might be able to pursue his claim for judicial review have been considered. Purely on the grounds for judicial review, Jackââ¬â¢s best chance of success lies with the danger of bias in the composition of the panel in the tribunal, given that one of his ex-girlfriends is a member of it. Jack might well, however, be able to strengthen his claim by supporting it with Human Rights Act claims. The impact of this will be considered on each of the possible grounds for review outlined above. Firstly, in respect of the decision by the tribunal not to allow Jack to be legally represented, it is possible that although this is not necessarily improper in itself, it may be a breach of Jackââ¬â¢s human rights as encompassed in the European Convention on Human Rights, incorporated into English law by the Human Rights Act 1998. The relevant article of the Convention is Article 6, which guarantees the right to a fair hearing. This entitles Jack, ââ¬Ëin the determination of his civil rights and obligations â⬠¦ to a fair and public hearing.ââ¬â¢[4] Firstly, does this cover tribunals of the sort Jack is involved in? In the case of Ringeisen v Austria (1971), the European Court held that Article 6(1) covers all proceedings whose result affects private rights and obligations. In the present instance, Jackââ¬â¢s right to continue working as a teacher is to be determined by the outcome of the tribunal. It seems then, that his case is at least covered by the Article. The Article only confirms that Jack would have a right to legal representation, however, if he were charged with a criminal offence. ââ¬ËEveryone charged with a criminal has the following minimal rights â⬠¦ to defend himself in person or through legal assistance â⬠¦Ã¢â¬â¢[5] This, however, is merely a civil offence, so once again, there is no guarantee that Jack should be granted legal representation under the ECHR. The same Article of the Convention is also applicable, however, to the composition of the tribunal panel as well as the manner in which the tribunal was conducted. Firstly, the Article guarantees the right to a ââ¬Ëfair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunalâ⬠¦Ã¢â¬â¢[6] In the European Court case of Langborger v Sweden (1989), the Court established that ââ¬Ëeven if individuals are technically qualified to address a given issue and even if there is no subjective reason to doubt their personal integrity, it is important that the appearance of objective impartiality and independence is observed.ââ¬â¢[7] More specifically, in the case of Sramek v Austria (1984), those adjudicating a particular matter cannot be seen to have a relationship with any of the parties. This case law clearly impacts upon Jackââ¬â¢s case, as the previous relationship he had with the female member of the panel can be seen to breach this principle of f airness and impartiality, despite her assurances that the history had no effect on her judgment. Furthermore, also under Article 6(1), the court or tribunal is required to give reasons for its decisions. Jackââ¬â¢s employment tribunal met this requirement insofar as it gave reasons for its refusal to allow Jack more than five witnesses, but it must also have given reasons for its unanimous decision to dismiss Jack. Perhaps linked to this is Jackââ¬â¢s right under the same Article to a ââ¬Ëfair hearingââ¬â¢. The fact that Jack noticed one of the panel was falling asleep during his defence hardly seems commensurate with this principle. He could conceivably, then, mount a challenge to the decision of the tribunal based on human rights claims under Article 6 of the ECHR. He would have two substantial avenues of challenge; firstly the impartiality of the tribunal could be called into question due to its inclusion of Jackââ¬â¢s ex-girlfriend. Secondly, the conduct of the tribunal itself, particularly the fact that a member of the panel was falling asleep during Jackâ⠬â¢s submission, suggests Jack would have a valid claim for breach of his rights. In this scenario, then, Jack would be able to establish grounds for his claim for judicial review. The tribunal is exercising a quasi-judicial function, and would be properly categorised as a public law function. As such, judicial review is the proper way to proceed to challenge its decisions. In terms of actual grounds for review, Jackââ¬â¢s best chances lie with the composition of the panel. The inclusion of his ex-girlfriend, despite the panelââ¬â¢s claim to the contrary, could be seen to have an adverse effect on the impartiality of the panel. Again, the falling asleep of one of the panelââ¬â¢s members during Jackââ¬â¢s presentation also gives ground for judicial review due to procedural impropriety. It seems the panel has acted within its rights to deny legal representation to Jack. Nor is this legal representation guaranteed under human rights legislation, as this is clearly a civil matter, while the ECHR only guarantees legal representation in criminal cases. Again , in the context of the Human Rights Act 1998, Jackââ¬â¢s best chances of mounting a strong case for breach of his rights lies in the composition of the panel and the conduct of the hearing. These seem to have constituted potential breaches of Article 6 of the ECHR. BIBLIOGRAPHY Statutes Civil Procedure Rules 1999 European Convention on Human Rights Housing (Homeless Persons) Act 1977 Human Rights Act 1998 Tribunals and Inquiries Act 1992 Cases Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 Clark v University of Lincolnshire and Humberside [2000] 3 All ER 752 Cocks v Thanet District Council [1983] 2 AC 286 Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374 Langborger v Sweden (1989) Oââ¬â¢reilly v Mackman [1983] 2 AC 237 Pett v Greyhound Racing Association [1969] 1 QB 125 Porter v Magill [2001] UKHL 67 R v Board of Visitors of HM Prison, the Maze, ex p Hone [1988] AC 379 R v Chief Constable of Sussex, ex p International Traderââ¬â¢s Ferry Ltd [1999] 2 AC 418 R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club, ex p Aga Khan [1993] 2 All ER 853 R v Gough [1993] AC 646 R v Legal Aid Board, ex p Donn Co [1996] 3 All ER 1 R v Panel on Take-overs and Mergers, ex p Datafin plc [1987] QB 815 R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Brind [1991] 1 AC 696 Ringeisen v Austria (1971) Roy v Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Family Practitioner Committee [1992] 1 AC 624 Sramek v Austria (1984) Secondary sources Gomien, D. (2005) Short Guide to the European Convention on Human Rights (Strasbourg: Council of Europe) Leyland, P., and Woods, T. (2002) Textbook on Administrative Law, 4th Edition (Oxford: OUP) Parpworth, N. (2004) Constitutional and Administrative Law, 3rd Edition (London: LexisNexis) Footnotes [1] See, for example, Parpworth, N. (2004) Constitutional and Administrative Law, 3rd Edition (London: LexisNexis), p264 [2] Quoted in Parpworth, p270 [3] Quoted ibid, p309 [4] European Convention on Human Rights, Article 6(1) [5] Ibid, Article 6(3)(c) [6] Ibid, Article 6(1) [7] Quoted in Gomien, D. (2005) Short Guide to the European Convention on Human Rights (Strasbourg: Council of Europe), p56
Recruiting Nurses in Rural Communities
Recruiting Nurses in Rural Communities B. Trimble Perceptions of nurse practitioner students on clinical rotations in rural health care areas, and the likelihood of practicing in a rural area. With the current primary care provider shortages in rural areas, could the key be the use of nurse practitioners, to ultimately, fill the gap in medical services? How satisfied are patients with a nurse practitionerââ¬â¢s services? How do communities recruit and keep nurse practitioners? What role do rural clinical rotations play in the recruitment of nurse practitioner graduates for practice in rural areas? Rural communities have difficulty recruiting and retaining primary care providers. With the number of aging providers looking at retirement and the lack of medical school graduates interested in primary care, the need will be further increased. The national shortage of primary care providers has many communities searching for help. Meeting the current needs is difficult and the need for services is expected to increase as the rural population ages and the enactment of the patient protection and affordable care act. Advanced practice registered nurses, whom studies show can provide care that is safe and as effective as a physician, are a powerful solution to the problem of the shortage in primary care providers and rising health care costs. There are currently 189,000 nurse practitioners, 35,000 nurse anesthetist, and 18,500 certified nurse-midwives in the United States according to the American Association of Nurse Practitioners (American Association of Nurse Practitioners, 2014). Nurse practitioners play a pivotal role in providing necessary medical care to the underserved of rural communities. A need for studies that examine the experiences of rural health care providers, to assess the barriers and the facilitators for nurse practitioner practice are needed. Offering mentorships, in the rural areas, may be another way to increase interest of the nurse practitioners in rural areas. As the new health care laws become effective, the need will increase. The purpose of this study is to examine how incorporating rural health rotations, in training of nurse practitioner students, may improve on the recruitment of nurse practitioner graduates into the rural healthcare sector. In rural health centers, nurse practitioners fill key leadership positions. In a study on rural health clinic efficiency and the impacts made by nurse practitioners and physician assistants, indicated that rural health centers that used nurse practitioners had a high rate for expertise in quality care and cost effectiveness (Ortiz, Wan, Meemon, Paeth, Agiro, 2010). The purpose of the study was to investigate the impact of nurse practitioners to rural health clinics yield, determine the association of proficiency indicators, and understand specific and organizational factors that affect productivity. The questions posed were as follows: Does rural health clinicââ¬â¢s performance vary contingent on nurse practitioner staffing? To what extent do nurse practitioners influence productivity? What are characteristics of highly productive rural health clinics? (Ortiz, Wan, Meemon, Paeth, Agiro, 2010). . The study suggests that, employments of higher portions of nurse practitioners has a definite stance on productivity, and are able to handle a larger number of patients without adding professional staff. Process efficiency in clinics with a large percent of licensed staff tends to use larger numbers of nurse practitioners. Clinic size is definitely associated with industrial efficiency. The larger the clinicââ¬â¢s professional percentage, the higher the efficiency or production observed. The clinics able to maximize the value of nurse practitioners are the most cost effective in providing health care amenities. The conclusion of the study was that the use of nurse practitioners and physician assistants increased productivity and cost effectiveness in clinics that maximized the use of these medical professionals. There is a need for further studies to determine the contribution of nurse practitioners. Future research would involve risk adjustment factors to assess the effects of patient demographics and socioeconomic aspects. In addition, the evaluation of observational information would provide a better understanding of the nurse practitioner involvments. (Ortiz, Wan, Meemon, Paeth, Agiro, 2010). In a study conducted by Ryan and Rahman in urgent care centers, to determine what factors influence the satisfaction of care provided by nurse practitioners, it was determined that the care provided was scored positive. The scores were higher for those noted to be uninsured as compared to those with insurance. A descriptive study including four urgent care centers using two to four nurse practitioners was used for the study. Two of the four urgent care centers were excluded from the study, due to weather conditions. Patients were asked to complete a post visit review and sealed in an envelope after completion. Participant inclusion was they had to be 18 years of age, be able to read, write and comprehend English. The survey contained five questions on demographics and thirteen items where ten assessed the clarity of the nurse practitioner role. Approval was granted from Shenandoah University IRB and the four participating urgent care centers. No enhancements were offered to participants for participation in the study. Examining factors that affect patient satisfaction, with nurse practitioners in rural urgent care centers studies showed that there was a high rate of patient satisfaction regardless of age, insurance, race, or gender. The clarity of the nurse practitioner role was significantly different between participants that were uninsured as compared to those with insurance. The uninsured rated the experience higher than those with insurance. The overall scores for satisfaction with care were positive. Several of the patients were unaware they were being treated by nurse practitioners until the after treatment survey. This implies that the care was comparable to what had been provided by physicians in the past. The American healthcare system has not been able to meet the demands for accessible, low-cost medical care. Rural areas face a shortage of healthcare providers as family physicians retire and current graduate physicians decide to enter into specialties rather than general practice. Nurs e practitioners can fill the gap in medical providers. The role of the nurse practitioner is on the increase in rural areas that are underserved and are well accepted by colleagues and patients. Nurse practitioners provide competent care; this and previous studies have confirmed that patients are highly satisfied with primary care provided by nurse practitioners (Ryan, 2012). In a qualitative study by Boynton Sharp, to explore the factors related to the recruitment and retaining of nurse practitioners in rural areas, it was determined that nurse practitioners are more likely to accept a position in rural healthcare after having completed at least one clinical practicum in a rural setting (Boynton Sharp, 2010). In this study, the sample size was 29 nurse practitioners from across the United States. The data collection method was semi-structured interviews. Analysis of categories and themes determined that three of the concepts of rural nursing theory were applicable. It was anticipated that the knowledge gained would contribute to understanding nurse practitioner choices to practice in rural areas, to determine the developing rural nurse practitioner educational programs and existing federal agencies involved in recruiting and retainment nurse practitioners, in rural areas. A qualitative study using a focused ethnographic approach was used to explore the cultural construction of rural nurse practitioner roles. A conceptual model analysis from the theory of cultural marginality was developed. The marginality framework was developed to provide a basis for data collection and analysis. Data set used interviews conducted using audio/video tapes of electronic media interviews through web conferencing, except two interviews were conducted by telephone. Data analysis was through transcription of interviews; at the end of the analysis three concepts from the rural nursing theory were identified. Lack of anonymity was subdivided into respect and annoyance. Outsider versus insider status was defined, not as being an insider in the community, but as an outsider in the medical community. Permission to conduct the study was granted by the University of Texas at El Pasoââ¬â¢s IRB. Names of participants did not appear anywhere in the report or research. This study identified the three concepts of the rural nursing theory. In the study, the nurse practitioners did not find the lack of anonymity to be an annoyance, but viewed it as a part of being an effective medical care provider. The study indicated that nurse practitioners are well accepted by the community members. However, nurse practitioners are not always accepted by the existing medical community. Self-reliance was indicated by the nurse practitionerââ¬â¢s ability to function alone and make independent decisions related to their clinical practice. Due to differences between urban and rural care needs, it is important that nurse practitioner students be given an appreciation for the uniqueness and benefits of rural practice including a) limited access to healthcare, b) limited resources, and c) distance to specialists. This can be accomplished through changes in didactic and clinical components of nurse practitioner educational programs. Nurse practitioners who accept positions in rural areas most often have a background in rural areas, have participated in a rural training program, or have a desire to serve in a rural community. Completion of a rural program is associated with accepting a position in a rural practice. In this study, 72% of the nurse practitioners completed at least one rural clinical practicum. This supports the importance of rural training as an effective strategy in recruitment of nurse practitioners for rural areas (Boynton Sharp, 2010). In another study published by Purdue University (Richards, 2011) stated that as practitioner students are subjected to underserved populations, they are able to better understand the complicated clinical situation, which also confronts nurse practitioners to provide valuable and professional, high quality safe and cost efficient patient care. The practitioner students rotated through the clinics; this was found to improve the staff role in clinical knowledge, strengthen the evidence of clinically relevant research, and enhance the classroom instructions and assignments. The rotations made class instruction and assignments more meaningful when the students observed the instruction being used in a clinical setting. The experience integrated previous subject matter and allowed practitioner students to develop skills in a supportive and strengthened environment. Allowing students to perform alongside nurse practitioners, help to develop mentoring and educational relationships, regard for others capability, and improves comprehension of the nurse practitioner role. The staff roles shifted from the expert to a mutually supportive learning association (Richards, 2011). The advanced practice nurse can serve to fill the gap in primary health care. Nurse practitioners can provide quality, cost effective care to these communities, offsetting the limited access and rising health care costs. Access to primary health care is essential in maintaining and improving health. Those who have regular primary health care receive more preventative services, are more likely to comply with prescribed treatments, and have lower rates of illness and preventive deaths. To ensure recruitment and retainment of nurse practitioners in these areas, it is important to increase the nurse practitioner student experience with clinical rotations in rural or underserved areas. References American Association of Nurse Practitioners. (2014). NP Fact Sheet. Retrieved from AANP.org: http://www.aanp.org/all-about-nps/np-fact-sheet Boynton Sharp, D. M. (2010). Factors related to the recruitment and retention of nurse practitioners in rural areas. (3409167), 110. Ann Arbor, Mi, United States: ProQuest, LLC. Retrieved March 29, 2014, from http://search.proquest.com.southuniversity.libproxy.edmc.edu/docview/613695577?accountid=87314 Ortiz, J., Wan, T., Meemon, N., Paeth, S., Agiro, A. (2010, July/August). Contextual Correlates of Rural Health Clinics Efficiency: Analysis of Nurse Practitioners Contributions. Journal for Health Care Leaders, 28(4), 237-44. Retrieved March 20, 2014, from http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/729490_1 Richards, E. (2011). The role of nursing students at two rural nurse managed health clinics. School of Nursing Faculty Publications (paper 4). Purdue University. Doi:10.1080/07370016.2011.539086 Ryan, K. D.-C. (2012, February 1). Examining Factors Influencing Patient Satisfaction With Nurse Practitioners in Rural Urgent Care Centers. Journal of American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 24(2), 77-81. Doi:10.1111/j.1745.7599.2011.00688.x
Saturday, July 20, 2019
Attitudes to War in Dulce et Decorum est and Drummer Hodge. Essay
Attitudes to War in Dulce et Decorum est and Drummer Hodge. Life wasn't easy for soldiers in the war as Wilfred Owen and Thomas Hardy express strongly in their legendary poems 'Dulce et Decorum est' and 'Drummer Hodge'. Peter Porter writes about the situation people may find themselves in when in, his poem 'Your Attention Please', he describes an announcement concerning a nuclear Rocket Strike. Wilfred Owen died at the age of 25 and was killed seven days before the end of World War 1. He is regarded as one of the most well-known war poets of the 20th Century, having written an astonishing 110 poems. Under the influence of Romantic, early 19th Century poets such as Wordsworth, Keats and Shelley, Owen produced 'Dulce Et Decorum Est' which revealed the truth behind war, the grief and suffering caused. Wilfred Owen wanted to dismiss the idea of romance as a motivation to fight in the war; young men believed that fighting in the war would make them heroes and that girls would be passionate about them. Of course many men didn't have an option in the matter: wives and girlfriends chose not to stay with their man if they didn't fight in the war, so men were forced to join up. The fact that their partner wouldn't stick by them was one reason but if they didn't join the whole society would look down on them with disgrace: they weren't men if they didn't fight for their country. "Dulce Et Decorum Est" speaks about the severe drowsiness of the soldiers on their way back from the front line and the sudden panic caused when the soldiers are hit unexpectedly with a gas attack. The poem begins with a simile, "Bent double, like old beggars under sacks". This indicates the extent of the load the men had to carry with... ...uses similes such as "like a man in fire or lime" where the man is in pain and is struggling to stay alive. Alliteration is used in both Owen and Hardy's poems. Most of Dulce et Decorum est is written in the 1st person perspective but many times it changes to 3rd person. When it's in 1st person it gives us the feeling of reality and truth behind the poem. In conclusion, war brings a great deal of pain and suffering so it shouldn't be under-estimated. Wilfred Owen, Thomas Hardy and Peter Porter all bring across the reality behind war and the torture it brings with it. Personally my favourite out of the three is "Dulce et Decorum est" as I know it's a true account of what happened in the war because Wilfred Owen was a soldier and died in action. I thought this poem contained a lot of discomfort and misery making it more out of the ordinary and authentic.
Friday, July 19, 2019
USS MAINE :: essays research papers
In the late 1800ââ¬â¢s the American people and their government became more willing to risk war in defense of American interests overseas, support for building a large modern navy began to grow. Supporters argued that if the United States did not build up its navy and acquire bases overseas, it would be shut out of foreign markets by Europeans. Captain Alfred T. Mahan observed that building a modern navy meant that the U.S. had to acquire territory for naval bases overseas. This would enable them to operate a navy far from home. A country needed bases and coaling stations in distant regions, which was exactly what they did by having Havana, Cuba be one of its ports. Another factor that was part of the Navyââ¬â¢s modernization was the USS Maine, which was probably the most famous ship of its era. The USS Maine was one of the Navyââ¬â¢s first armored battle ships. It was one of the first U.S. naval vessels with electrical lighting. It had a top speed of 17 knots and a crew of 392 officers and enlisted men. On the evening of February 15, 1898 the USS Maine exploded. Of the 345 officers and sailors aboard the Maine, 266 died. There were many ideas of how this explosion occurred, namely: the shipââ¬â¢s ammunition supplies blew up, a fire accidentally ignited the ammunition, and that a mine detonated near the ship set off the ammunition. At the time Cuba was a Spanish colony, but it was in the midst of a revolution. The Cuban people were fighting for independence from Spain. During this Cuban revolt against Spain and the American battleship Maine dropped anchor in the Havana harbor to protect American interests in Cuba. Many Americans regarded the Spanish as tyrants and supported the Cubans in their struggle. This immediately made Americans jump to the Conclusion that Spain blew up the Maine. Americanââ¬â¢s felt that since they were allies with Cuba that Spain was trying to harm America, as to not interfere with Cubaââ¬â¢s revolt against them. With in a matter of weeks, Spain and the U. USS MAINE :: essays research papers In the late 1800ââ¬â¢s the American people and their government became more willing to risk war in defense of American interests overseas, support for building a large modern navy began to grow. Supporters argued that if the United States did not build up its navy and acquire bases overseas, it would be shut out of foreign markets by Europeans. Captain Alfred T. Mahan observed that building a modern navy meant that the U.S. had to acquire territory for naval bases overseas. This would enable them to operate a navy far from home. A country needed bases and coaling stations in distant regions, which was exactly what they did by having Havana, Cuba be one of its ports. Another factor that was part of the Navyââ¬â¢s modernization was the USS Maine, which was probably the most famous ship of its era. The USS Maine was one of the Navyââ¬â¢s first armored battle ships. It was one of the first U.S. naval vessels with electrical lighting. It had a top speed of 17 knots and a crew of 392 officers and enlisted men. On the evening of February 15, 1898 the USS Maine exploded. Of the 345 officers and sailors aboard the Maine, 266 died. There were many ideas of how this explosion occurred, namely: the shipââ¬â¢s ammunition supplies blew up, a fire accidentally ignited the ammunition, and that a mine detonated near the ship set off the ammunition. At the time Cuba was a Spanish colony, but it was in the midst of a revolution. The Cuban people were fighting for independence from Spain. During this Cuban revolt against Spain and the American battleship Maine dropped anchor in the Havana harbor to protect American interests in Cuba. Many Americans regarded the Spanish as tyrants and supported the Cubans in their struggle. This immediately made Americans jump to the Conclusion that Spain blew up the Maine. Americanââ¬â¢s felt that since they were allies with Cuba that Spain was trying to harm America, as to not interfere with Cubaââ¬â¢s revolt against them. With in a matter of weeks, Spain and the U.
Thursday, July 18, 2019
Ethics Essay Essay
What is Ethics? It is the binding good character, being respectful, and having trustworthiness amongst others. The topics that will be touched on is the differences between morality and ethical theories. Finally, I am going to touch on my personal experiences in relation to virtue, values, and moral concepts. Morality and ethics are almost one in the same in the greater scheme of things. They both work together to make up ethical decisions by a person. For example there are five key terms that breaks down the theories; which are Consequential, Egoism, Utilitarian, Act Utilitarian, and Rule Utilitarianism. Therefore, ethical theories and moral theories are broken down into two different categories consequential and non-consequential theories. Now what is the consequential theory exactly? The consequential theories basically mean, the result of a personââ¬â¢s behavior can result in either morally good consequences or morally bad consequences (Manias & Monroe, 2013). The breakdown can go even further; in the simplest terms morality relates to non-consequential theories and ethical decisions lead to consequential theories. For example, an ethical decision could be a police officer runs a red light, without having police sirens on; the consequence is a law abiding citizen might be further dissatisfied with the police force in the area. A moral decision is basically the action of right and wrong; which is really not a consequence. The decision of right and wrong is decided on oneself feelings about a certain scenario or person at any given time. For example, a student cheats on a test; why does he or she cheat? One may ask, is this situation right or wrong. The judgment or verdict is for you to decide, whether it is the person themselves; has good morals or not. One of the three theories that relate to me is Utilitarian. I have two children and I am always constantly trying to them to be well mannered and teach them good aspects of life. I myself always want to produce theà greatest possible good out of everything. Whether it is teaching my children something or making someone else laughs. In conclusion, ethical decisions can lead to misunderstandings and have great consequences. Moral decisions decide right and wrong. My personal experiences relating to Utilitarian theories are something that I now know about. It hoped that this explanation will help the further understanding of the subject. References Page Manias, N., & Monroe, D. (2013). Ethics Applied (7th ed.). http://about.nike.com/pages/sustainability
Assessment for Learning â⬠the Case for Formative Assessment Essay
This paper provides findings on judgement for learning, It begins with analysis of the fictile approach in exemplary approach pattern carried out in secondary checks in eight program line systems. The second half of the paper comprises primal analyses on formative estimate in adult language, literacy, and numeracy provision, and a framework for modify policy and practice across the domain as well as for construct the evidence base. Assessment is vital to the study process. In give lessonss, the most visible estimations atomic number 18 summational.Summative judgements are used to flier what schoolchilds nurture learnt at the end of a unit, to promote school-age childs, to ensure they have met postulate standards on the way to earning certification for school completion or to enter certain(a) occupations, or as a rule for selecting students for entry into further tuition. Ministries or departments of pedagogy may use additive assessments and military ratings as a way to hold publicly funded schools accountable for providing quality education.Increasingly, international summative assessments such as OECDs computer programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) have been important for comparing national education systems to developments in other countries. But assessment may also serve a formative function. In classrooms, formative assessment refers to frequent, interactive assessments of student progress and disposition to identify learning needs and queue up teaching appropriately.Teachers using formative assessment approaches and techniques are better prepared to tackle diverse students needs through specialisation and adaptation of teaching to raise levels of student achievement and to achieve a greater equity of student outcomes. But there are major barriers to wider practice, including perceived tensions betwixt classroom-based formative assessments, and high visibility summative tests to hold schools accountable f or student achievement, and a lack of connection between systemic, school and classroom approaches to assessment and evaluation.The principles of formative assessment may be applied at the school and policy levels, to identify areas for profit and to promote effective and constructive cultures of evaluation end-to-end education systems. More tenacious use of formative assessment throughout education systems may help stakeholders verbalize the very barriers to its wider practice in classrooms.This overview shows how formative assessment promotes the goals of lifelong learning, including higher levels of student achievement, greater equity of student outcomes, and change learning to learn skills. The chapter then discusses barriers to wider practice of formative assessment and ways in which those barriers can be addressed, and outlines the study cranial orbit and methodology. Meeting goals for lifelong learning from each one of the national and regional governments participatin g in this study promotes formative.
Wednesday, July 17, 2019
How Oil Shaped Post War World Essay
If one commodity merchantman claim credit for the startling advances seen in the human being in the 20th century, in particular in developed industrialised countries, it was cutting fossil fossil oil color- soon to be dubbed stark gold. Oil became an influential shopping mall in the house struggle times, scotchally and also in shaping countries strange policies. Whichever countries controlled petroleum colour controlled much of the cosmeas policies. After the plus in industrialization and manufacture in the smirch state of war times, anoint became a must set out resource, for a solid ground, in order for that people to grow economically and become a self-sustaining state.The premier(prenominal) bush-league boldness reite pointd the need to invade the Gulf as, a way to defend our way of animation in the form of acquiring and maintaining the tote up of cheap oil into the the Statesn interior. pose war rebuild was the main agendum as nigh nations fo ught to rebuild their states from the damage sustained during the two existence Wars. A drastic rise in the carry for oil in the world became proud and those nations that held oil resources had firm advantage everywhere those that did non provoke easy entrance to it.In this essay, an outline of the authority oil played in shaping post war worlds will be understandably discussed showing the various policies implemented by different nations in order to come through the imperative resource. The general change from blacken energy to oil energy was a catalyst for the increase in the judge of industrialisation. According to Yergin, Industrialisation sped up rapidly between the years 1949 and 1972. With economic recovery as the main focus of nigh nations tincted by the catastrophes of both piece Wars, oil had a vital role to play in each of the nations policies.With oil consumption triple in each and every state, governments had to hold for the low death rates which incr ease population, high employment exact and increase in consumption which meant more oil had to be imported in order for general recovery to be implemented. lacquer, regarding the demolition of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki atomic bombings, is one of the most bighearted in wide spread economic recovery quickly declared they were palliate from post war recovery in the early 1960s as a result of their adoption of oil for industry. government activity of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) was formed in Baghdad, Iraq on the 14th of September 1960 by Iran, Iraq, capital of capital of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Venezuela. Its formation was largely associated with the grievances Arab nations had against the exploitatory multinational Oil Companies that were gradually diminution oil prices to suit their Western infrastructure lands, had become powerful within the states they operated in and the oil companies boycott of the decree to modify all oil resources by Arab governments.OPEC meant to scud over the oil market and drop the power to decide for themselves the price and exertion levels of the resources that were within their nations interior. With the sure-fire capture of the oil resource by the Middle East nation, came large and untimed variations in price, production levels and the general supply of crude oil to the rest of the world. United States of the States and other global economies, already grave felt with other problems, were like a shot insecure to Middle East oil policies which could affect their nations economies and social well beings.Looking into post war Iraq, Saddam Husseins era was characterised by the need for gold to fund his expansion of uniting Arab nations into one nation under his political and Baathist ideologies. Hussein had Iraq export of crude oil as his main source of income even he met obstacles such as the Kuwait and United Arab Emirates (UAE) who had switched the OPEC policies to produce and sell oil at a fixed rate i n order to gain demand along as a substantial profit.Kuwait and UAE were now producing more oil than agreed in Baghdad in 1960 which resulted in more supply of oil than demanded thus reducing the price of crude oil to slight than $3 a barrel. Saddams retaliation was to jeopardise Kuwait and UAE with potential invasion if they did not adjust to the previously agreed policies to strengthen oil prices. Result was a Kuwait confirmation to Saddams demands just however led to a affray for aid funds which led to Iraki army invasion of Kuwait. Americas invasion of Iraqi territory was highlighted as one of the most controversial remote policies to get hold of been implemented by the American government.The Persian Gulf War first initiated by president George H. W. Bush and the second Persian Gulf War, implemented by the son of the former named president George W. Bush formed the most debated policies of post war era. Most studies have come up with their own reasons as to why America decided to advance on Iraq with most highlighting the need to establish a constant supply of oil at a reasonable price, while others studies have put out that America cherished strategic positioning over its affiliate and rivals, save Russia, of oil seeking nations.Although no(prenominal) have been verified by the American government, it is clear that the main reason for American invasion was for the sole purpose of set American position in the oil market. President George, W. Bush, the then American president, express himself that the war was, to defend our way of spirit this could be seen as a now implication on the need to have oil, a resource that is needed in America to support their economy.In conclusion, oil plays a vital role in shaping the world post to the World Wars. It is seemingly hard to believe that world recovery from such a lay waste to war could only take less than 50years leaving very little distinction that there was ever a war to begin with. America rem ains a major power within the world with oil reserves larger than either other nation China now boasts the worlds largest economy and Japan have recovered substantially for a nation that had very little resources to lean with.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)